About Practices Directory
Home: Practices: Civil/Structural Engineering: Case Studies: Earthquake Engineering

Case Studies: Earthquake Engineering

Wood Frame Structures Exponent investigated a four-story engineered structure with three stories of wood-frame construction over a one-story parking garage. Constructed in circa 1978, the building sustained serious damage in the first story of wood-frame construction during the January 17, 1994, Northridge earthquake, was red tagged (unsafe) by the City of Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety, and evacuated. An important observation from the investigation was on the mode of failure—the level of damage was significantly exacerbated by horizontal shear failure of the 3-ply, 3/8-inch thick plywood. The observed failure of 3/8-inch plywood indicated that, for closely nailed plywood, the expected ductility capacity of the plywood shearwalls would not be achieved. This indicated a clear defect in the building code—panels nailed so heavily that the failure mode was rupture of the plywood (a brittle, undesirable failure mode), a condition that should not be used in seismic applications.

Concrete and Tilt-Up Structures Exponent was retained by a high-tech company with facilities in Silicon Valley to conduct a seismic vulnerability study of two of its facilities that operated on a 24-hour-a-day, 7-day-a-week schedule. State-of-the-art deterministic and probabilistic seismic hazard/risk analysis, extensive field inspections, and structural analysis were used to determine the vulnerability of the buildings and contents. We found that the facilities missed the immediate occupancy/operational performance levels in many areas and did not satisfy the life-safety criterion in some areas for the seismic hazard considered. We worked with the client to provide solutions for seismic performance upgrades, within the facilities’ continued operation constraint, that would reduce the damage under severe ground shaking, minimize the chances of catastrophic failure, strengthen critical areas, and reduce the chance of extended downtime, while providing a cost-effective solution. Exponent has provided similar services for other commercial and industrial facilities, as well as historic buildings.

Steel Moment Frame Buildings Exponent was retained to investigate the extent of damage from the Northridge earthquake to particular steel buildings in Los Angeles, and to determine the causes leading to the unexpected damage. The investigation consisted of extensive field inspections, removal of samples, metallurgical analysis, detailed finite element analysis of connections, and extensive global structural analysis. In addition, we were asked to develop a new moment resisting connection that could reliably improve the performance of a particular SMRF building. Exponent assembled a cross-disciplinary team of in-house experts in structural engineering, earthquake engineering, fracture mechanics, metallurgical engineering, construction management, and economic systems coupled with experts from academia to fully address the issues posed and to develop an optimal strategy for repair.

Industrial Facilities Exponent was retained to assess the overall seismic risk for the three largest oil refineries in Turkey for TUPRAS (Turkish Petroleum Refinery) following the 1999 earthquake that struck western Turkey. The assessment included a detailed and extensive field investigation coupled with structural analysis for the various components and structures, especially storage tanks, stacks and chimneys, and frame structures. Our investigation helped identify hierarchically the seismically vulnerable components within each refinery and provided a foundation for staging proactive seismic upgrades, thereby reducing the seismic risk to the refineries.

top | back | next