About Practices Directory
Home: Practices: Human Factors: Case Studies

Case Studies

Trampoline Injury Analysis A manufacturer of backyard trampolines asked us to analyze the risk of injury associated with the use of their product, compare it to the risks of other recreational activities, and develop appropriate warnings and other safety information. Safety messages were developed to warn about the accident patterns and user behaviors that were related to injuries as determined from our analysis of the accident data and scientific literature. We refined the words and pictures used in the warnings based on responses from potential and actual trampoline users.
Unintended Acceleration Related to Pedal Error So-called "unintended acceleration" in all makes of automobiles occurs when the driver enters the parked vehicle, starts it, and then shifts to Drive. Reportedly, the vehicle runs away at full throttle, and the brakes have no effect, leaving the driver to claim that the vehicle malfunctioned. Our analysis of these accidents reveals that the driver unknowingly made a pedal error, placing the right foot on the accelerator rather than the brake. We have worked with nearly all of the automakers in these situations, providing evidence supporting a human-factors explanation rather than a mechanical one. We examined other types of pedal errors that occur during driving, showing that unintended acceleration is but a small percentage of pedal errors generally. One implication of this project is the notion that the design of automobile pedals must be considered far more broadly than just in terms of unintended-acceleration episodes.
Child Safety Seat Installation Study Analysis of accident data shows that child safety seats reduce the chance of injury to young children in motor vehicle accidents. Issues related to proper installation of child safety seats are frequently raised when a child in a safety seat is injured in a motor vehicle accident. We recently studied how parents installed a child safety seat in a motor vehicle. We measured the amount of force young children were able to apply to release different styles of latches, and demonstrated that the lack of a locking clip on the motor vehicle's seatbelt in this incident allowed the child to loosen the restraint system without unfastening it.

Visibility and Driver Behavior Nighttime motor vehicle accidents frequently raise issues of whether a reasonable driver could have seen a hazard in time to take action and avoid an impact. One approach involves analysis of the visibility of the hazard, based on lighting measurements and data; the likelihood of visibility can be estimated, and specific scenarios can be represented in computer-generated displays or animations. Another approach involves using test charts to study contrast detection in the actual lighting conditions of the accident scene; the measurements can be used as a basis for preparing representative photographic images. In either case, final evaluation includes considering typical driver perception and response time, as well as factors that may have influenced behavior in the circumstances of a particular accident.

top