About Practices Directory
Home: Practices: Materials/Metallurgy: Case Studies: Materials/Metallurgy

Case Studies:

Service Generator Failure Investigation The U.S. Coast Guard icebreakers Polar Sea and Polar Star operate for weeks at a time in polar ice, where failure of a vital system could be disastrous. An electrical fire in a ship's service generator occurred when the studs securing the poles to the rotor fractured. The Coast Guard selected Exponent to assess the cause of the failure, and to review the rotor design. Fractographic analysis identified high-cycle fatigue as the root cause. After a detailed stress analysis of the rotor/pole attachment, Exponent provided the Coast Guard with guidelines for the selection of replacement studs in six affected generators aboard the two icebreakers.

Brake Cylinder Assessment A collision of a truck with a passenger car resulted in several injuries and deaths. The truck brakes had failed, and inspections of the rubber primary-cup seal in the master cylinder revealed a tear. A finite element model of the seal was constructed to evaluate the forces on the seal during service. Examination of the fracture surface using a special low-vacuum scanning electron microscope showed that the failure was not related to fatigue or a preexisting material defect. We showed that the cup seal was manufactured without defects, alternative failure scenarios were not possible, and that the failure was related to excessive wear.

Cardiovascular Implant Evaluation Radiography of an implantable cardiovascular device indicated a defect-free product. After removal, one of the high-strength, corrosion-resistant wires contained in the device was found to be broken. Exponent was asked to determine if the wire was broken as a result of the stresses imposed during removal. Scanning electron microscopy of the wire fracture surface clearly indicated that the crack had grown over time and was present prior to explant, but was not wide enough to have been detected by x-rays. Failure occurred when stresses imposed during the explant process caused the already cracked wire to break.

top